Sunday, September 1, 2024

Twisting the Talmud

 


The sheer ignorance on full display on social media is reminiscent of the 1930s and even earlier.  The attack on the Jewish people is in full swing but branded as anti-Zionist.  Make no mistake, these people really do HATE the Jews.  What's new?  Nothing; they are saying out loud.  Ronnie and Jim delve into the ignorance to shed light on this troubling trend.  Does the Talmud actually condone pedophilia and other disgusting charges?  In actuality, it's all baseless claims and nothing new.  The same propaganda has been plaguing the world throughout the centuries.  Don't take the word of populist loudmouths on X or Facebook, do some research yourself, without the confirmation bias.  You might be surprised to learn how brilliant the Talmud actually is.

Some things were written and make up the Torah and Tanach. Others were passed down orally.  Quite a simple premise.  Without the oral instructions what exactly would be circumcised? Perhaps your nose.  Then there how to slaughter and this statement "As I commanded you:" This teaches us that there is a (detailed) command concerning slaughter – how to slaughter – and these are the laws of slaughter that were taught to Moshe from Sinai (i.e., from G-d).” - Rashi

Then of course there's the no working on Shabbat.  What does that mean?  What is work? God didn't leave much up to the imagination as He was pretty specific.  Throughout the Tanach we could probably guess what constitutes work, yet the Talmud discusses the topic at length. 

The complexity of understanding the Talmud is a life-long journey.  It's not for everyone and shouldn't be. Leave it to the dedicated few that hold the mission of being the light unto the Nations.  A little story that I revere greatly:

THE CHIMNEY SWEEP CONVERSATION – LEARNING GEMARA 

A young man asks to study with a Talmudic scholar. The scholar gives him a taste of 

Talmudic reasoning. 

“But I already know logic, what do I need Talmudic reasoning?” protests the student, 

“Aristotelian syllogisms, truth-functional logic, predicate logic, set theory everything.” 

“That’s not Jewish logic,” replies the scholar, but the student persists, and so the scholar 

offers to show him the difference between “logic” and what we find in the Talmud. 

“Here is the question,” says the scholar. “Two men go down a chimney. One has a dirty face, 

one has a clean face. Which one washes?” 

“That’s easy,” says the student, “the one with the dirty face.” 

“Wrong,” says the scholar. “The one with the clean face looks at the other one, sees a dirty 

face, and thinks his must also be dirty, and so the one with the clean face washes.” 

“I see,” says the student. “It is a little more complicated than I thought, but I can do this. 

Please test me again.” 

“All right,” sighs the scholar. “Here is the question. Two men go down a chimney. One has a 

dirty face, one has a clean face. Which one washes?” 

In surprise the student answers, “Just as you said, the one with the clean face washes.” 

“Wrong,” says the scholar. “The one with the dirty face observes his companion looking at 

him and making ready to wash his face. ‘Ah ha,’ he thinks. ‘He must see a dirty face, and it’s 

mine.’ And so the one with the dirty face washes.” 

“It is even more complicated than I yet realized,” says the student, “but now I do 

understand. Please test me once more.” 

“Just once more,” says the scholar. “Here is the question. Two men go down a chimney. One 

has a dirty face, one has a clean face. Which one washes?” 

“Now I know the answer,” says the student. “The one with the dirty face washes, just as I 

thought in the beginning, but for a different reason.” 

“Wrong,” says the scholar. “If two men go down a chimney, how can only one have a dirty 

face? Go and study. When you know Jewish logic, come back.”

https://staff-assets.ncsy.org/THE-CHIMNEY-SWEEP-QUESTION-%E2%80%93-LEARNING-TALMUD.pdf


There's a war taking place, and the aim is to destroy Judaism.  It's nothing new, just re-packaged old propaganda. 


https://www.thejc.com/news/features/meet-the-three-jews-behind-the-four-opinions-onlyconnect-team-cghd8o7f

Online antisemites’ new frontier? The Talmud https://www.thejc.com/news/features/online-antisemites-new-frontier-the-talmud-jlqnzyo4?utm_source=sharebutton&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=top via @JewishChron 

Ted Pike’s Confused Understanding:

https://youtu.be/bmRFU0GMDOo?feature=shared

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/burning-of-the-talmud

https://aish.com/when-king-louis-ix-burned-the-talmud/

https://outreachjudaism.org/lets-get-biblical-audio-series/

https://pathwaysradio.org/

Twisting the Talmud

  The sheer ignorance on full display on social media is reminiscent of the 1930s and even earlier.  The attack on the Jewish people is in f...